
A commenter on one of my previous posts has tipped me off to a new HD web video service called Motionbox. As a big fan of HD's convergence on the web, I was obviously intrigued. I shot over to
www.motionbox.com for a tour of their site, and services. I actually spent quite a bit of time learning about what they have to offer, and seeing how it might fit into my current workflow for web video. When all was said and done, I had an account and was up and running uploading a 356MB file. I did lots of playing around with my new 30 day free trial of the premium service. One of the things to keep in mind about motionbox is that it was created to be a revenue generating service for those individuals looking to have a more private and ad-free online video service. That being said, their premium account runs $29.99 per year and includes quite a bit of features for the price. Now, one thing I will say up front before anyone runs out and starts uploading everything they've got here, is that one of my golden rules is to never rely on an online video service for the primary storage of content. For premium members, Motionbox has unlimited storage space, which is great, though however tempting it may be, I warn you... Never delete your original videos from your pc. The bottom line is that you never know when a web 2.0 startup like this will go belly-up. Now to the real constructive portion of my comments about the Motionbox concept. While it definately is the best online HD video service I have used, it's not without some drawbacks. I will point out the two biggest drawbacks that I found in my tests. The first thing I noticed about the upload system that I didn't like is the fact that there is no way of uploading a video without it being transcoded. That's a problem because every time a video is transcoded there is quality loss. If there were an option to upload my own H.264 encoded files using the recommended bitrate settings at 1280x720 I would be one step closer to buying into the premium service. The other drawback that I noticed comes with watching the HD videos. As you know, HD video has some pretty steep requirements in order to playback smoothly on a computer. That said, these videos draw what I consider to be excessive processor requirements. I tested the videos out on three different systems, first was the 2.4Ghz dual core iMac I use for editing, second was my trusty 2.16Ghz dual core Macbook Pro, and third was my hottt gaming PC at home with a tri-core phenom processor. The video played back relatively smooth on the imac and phenom pc, however there were problems on the MBP with stuttering and choppy playback. It seems that the fullscreen playback mode draws more than my Macbook Pro can offer. This was odd to me because I have never had any trouble playing back 1280x720 content on it before. My concern is that the majority of people I would want to view my videos aren't even running a system that could meet these demands for fullscreen playback. If Motionbox can get these issues worked out I will very much consider a premium membership. If you've tried this out as well, please let me know what you think.